Sticker Guy Reviews

Sticker Guy has an overall rating of 4.1 based on 67 reviews. Customer feedback on Sticker Guy is mixed: Sticker Guy reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality stickers, fast shipping, excellent customer service, wide variety of designs, which strongly appeal to individuals and businesses looking for custom stickers. However, Sticker Guy is often criticized for its higher prices than competitors, limited customization options, occasional shipping delays, website navigation issues.

4.1/5.0

67 reviews

5 Stars

10

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

6

2 Stars

1

1 Star

0

All Sticker Guy Reviews (67)
michael1990
May 18, 2026
"I stuck one of these on my water..."
I stuck one of these on my water bottle and another on my toolbox just to see how they’d hold up. The water bottle’s been wet a bunch of times, and the toolbox gets knocked around often, but neither sticker has started peeling at all. i’m happy with them.
michael2000
May 16, 2026
"The colors came out okay, but the smaller..."
The colors came out okay, but the smaller text was kind of blurry. At this point I’m a bit tired of dealing with print issues, so I’ll probably just live with it, but it wasn’t as sharp as I’d hoped
cheryl.Young
April 25, 2026
"Super clean cuts"
i mean, the stickers came out really clean. Even the tiny edges were cut perfectly and everything looked just right.
ARLEDGE
April 14, 2026
"Really happy with my stickers"
First time ordering from stickerguy.com and it was easy all around. Uploaded my design with no fuss, and the stickers showed up looking pretty much exactly how I pictured.
Shipping was on time, quality feels solid, no weird issues. Simple, smooth order. I’d definitely use them again.
beverly1988
April 12, 2026
"I run a tiny candle shop and ordering..."
I run a tiny candle shop and ordering from them was easy. They didn’t push me into some huge order, the pricing felt reasonable, and the stickers turned out really nice. I’ll admit, after I paid I got a little distrustful and started wondering if the quality would actually match what they promised, but everything showed up looking good. It felt like they actually care about smaller customers too. I’d use them again
hello_kristina250
April 08, 2026
"Whoa, these showed up fast"
I ordered some stickers kind of last minute and had that instant “oh no, I hope these get here in time” feeling after checking out. But they showed up way faster than I expected, which was such a relief because I needed them for an event. Everything looked good, arrived on time, and the whole process was super easy. I’d definitely order again.
Charles-spiney
March 03, 2026
"Decent stickers, but not the most durable"
I ordered a few stickers from Sticker Guy because I’d been meaning to put something on my water bottle, which has been looking way too plain since I peeled off an old brewery sticker last month. When they showed up, they looked good overall. The print was clean, the colors were nice, and the material felt solid enough at first.
I stuck a couple on my laptop and one on the water bottle I take with me pretty much everywhere, including to work and errands and the gym when I remember to go. After a few weeks, I noticed some of the edges starting to lift a little. It wasn’t a disaster or anything, but I was hoping they’d stay put longer without needing to press them back down.

For the price, I’d say they’re decent, just not the toughest stickers I’ve used. I’d probably order again if I needed stickers for notebooks, packaging, or something that stays indoors, but I’m not sure I’d rely on them for anything that gets handled a lot or tossed around in a bag.
Travis-stringham
February 24, 2026
"Well, They Actually Got It Right"
My stickers showed up exactly how I ordered them, which feels like it shouldn’t be impressive, but here we are. The size, colors, and count were all right, and there weren’t any mix-ups or random weird mistakes. So yeah, I’m happy with it.
esther_Roosevelt01
February 22, 2026
"Upload issues totally messed up my plans"
I tried uploading my artwork a few different times and it just kept acting weird. It wasn’t clear what the problem was, so I ended up wasting way more time than I expected. I had planned to get this done and move on with my day, but instead I was stuck fighting with the upload and it pretty much threw off my whole schedule. Really frustrating.
nicholle_Berry85
February 01, 2026
"The colors just felt right"
I don’t know how else to put it, but the colors came out really good. They matched the way I was hoping, and it just felt right when I saw them.
THOMASON
February 01, 2026
"Super easy proofing, honestly"
The proofing was really quick and easy, like... I didn’t have to overthink anything. Making a few tweaks was simple too, so yeah, overall it was a smooth experience.
mauro1993
January 31, 2026
"Shipping was, seriously, so fast"
It showed up way sooner than I thought it would, which was, a really nice surprise
BobCole
January 30, 2026
"They made my sticker order right"
I had an issue with my sticker order, so I reached out to see what could be done. From my experience, they handled it smoothly and got everything sorted without making it a hassle. The main thing for me was that the problem got fixed, and they followed through.
james-Diaz
January 18, 2026
"Good prices on custom stickers"
The prices was fair for custom stickers, and I was happy with how they came out. Shipping was a little more than I expected, but overall it was still a decent deal.
DavidSmith_33
January 17, 2026
"I found what I needed without too..."
I found what I needed without too much trouble, actually. The site was fine overall, but the checkout felt a little clunky and could be smoother.
ErinHartwell_86
January 17, 2026
"took a while to get help"
i ordered some stickers from stickerguy.com and the stickers themselves turned out fine. customer service was just a little slow getting back to me. i had a question about my order and it took a couple days before i heard anything. they did reply eventually and were polite about it, but i wish the response time had been better. not the worst experience, but not amazing either.
TURNER
January 15, 2026
"My stickers arrived safely with no bends or..."
My stickers arrived safely with no bends or damage. The packaging was simple, and at first I wondered if it would be enough, but it ended up doing the job just fine
robert1974
December 30, 2025
"Decent bulk deal, but kind of slow"
I was happy with the bulk pricing and definitely saved some money, though at the same time I wouldn’t say it felt like an amazing bargain. Shipping took longer than I expected, which was annoying, but it wasn’t a huge deal in the end. Overall, it’s good for the price, even if I’m not totally thrilled with the whole experience.
heidibrooks1774
December 27, 2025
"Still looking good so far"
I ordered a few stickers from Sticker Guy for my toolbox and put one on my car window too. Lately they’ve been through some rain and a bunch of sun, and they still look solid. No peeling or curling that I’ve noticed. The colors might have faded just a little, but nothing that really bothers me. Shipping did take a bit longer than I expected, which is mainly why I’d give it 4 stars, but based on how they’ve held up recently, I’m happy with them...
WesleyFlens
December 07, 2025
"Good enough, but I wanted a little more"
I tried StickerGuy and the customization was easy to use overall. Picking the size and colors was simple, which I appreciated. I just wish there were more options for things like shapes and a better preview so I could really see how the final sticker would look. It’s not a bad experience at all, but it felt a little basic compared to what I had in mind. I came away feeling like it was fine, just not quite as exciting or flexible as I hoped.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Sticker Guy?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.